{"id":188037,"date":"1976-12-06T00:00:00","date_gmt":"1976-12-06T05:00:00","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.un.org\/unispal\/?p=188037"},"modified":"2019-07-11T15:55:55","modified_gmt":"2019-07-11T19:55:55","slug":"auto-insert-188037","status":"publish","type":"document","link":"https:\/\/www.un.org\/unispal\/document\/auto-insert-188037\/","title":{"rendered":"Mideast situation – Report of the CEIRPP, Report of the SecGen – Verbatim record"},"content":{"rendered":"
CONTENTS<\/p><\/div>\n
Agenda item 29:<\/p><\/div>\n
The situation in the Middle East (continued) <\/i><\/p><\/div>\n President: <\/i>Mr. Hamilton Shirley AMERASINGHE (Sri Lanka).<\/p><\/div>\n AGENDA ITEM 29 <\/strong><\/p><\/div>\n The situation in the Middle East <\/strong>(continued)<\/strong><\/i><\/p><\/div>\n 1.\t<\/span>The PRESIDENT: In connexion with this item, three draft resolutions have been submitted, in documents A\/31\/L.24, A\/31\/L.26 and A\/31\/L.27. Of these only document A\/31\/L.24 is before the Assembly at the <\/i>moment; the other two draft resolutions will be circulated shortly. In addition, amendments to draft resolution A\/31\/L.24 have been submitted in document A\/31\/L.25, which is before the Assembly.<\/p><\/div>\n 2.\t<\/span>Before calling on the next speaker in the debate, I shall on the representative of Israel, who wishes to introduce (draft resolution A\/31 \/L.24.<\/p><\/div>\n 3.\t<\/span>Mr. HERZOG (Israel): Thank you, Mr. President, for I, permitting me to make a further statement in introducing I this draft resolution.<\/p><\/div>\n 4.\t<\/span>I present to the Assembly draft resolution A\/31 \/L.24, which has been submitted by the delegation of Israel under agenda item 29 and which reads as follows:<\/p><\/div>\n The speaker then read out the text of draft resolution .24.<\/i>1<\/u>\/<\/p><\/div>\n 5.\t<\/span>The draft resolution follows the many statements made by the Government of Israel in which my Government's willingness to enter into negotiations with the Arab countries involved in the Middle East conflict was reiterated. It follows a statement by the Prime Minister of Israel the Socialist International in Geneva only some 10 days in which he proposed that a parallel be drawn between Geneva Peace Conference on the Middle East and the Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe, held L Helsinki. As he stated:<\/p><\/div>\n "Coexistence, security, trade, technology, co-operation 3 and human bridges- these are the essence of the Helsinki baskets. And I buy them. I buy them as the essence of an agenda for a Geneva conference on security and co-operation in the Middle East. For lasting peace is a matter of relations and exchange between peoples. Not only Governments. " [87th meeting, para. 145.]<\/i><\/p><\/div>\n 6.\t<\/span>This is, to the best of my knowledge, the first draft resolution ever submitted by Israel for consideration by the General Assembly. We bring it in the full knowledge that there is a feeling abroad that the Middle East can move towards peace today. We do so in full knowledge that there is no possibility for the Middle East to move towards peace without a renewal of the process of negotiation between the States parties to the conflict. For years we have maintained that the only way in which to move the area to peace is through direct negotiations, face to face. <\/p><\/div>\n 7.\t<\/span>Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµ created a mechanism, namely the Geneva Peace Conference, which has already brought about two disengagement agreements—one between Israel and Egypt and one between Syria and Israel—and an interim agreement between Israel and Egypt. Why not activate this mechanism immediately so that we can sit down together and negotiate? Our position is crystal clear. We want peace, and we are prepared to compromise for peace, real peace between countries, as the ordinary man in the street understands the word "peace".<\/p><\/div>\n 8.\t<\/span>If, as our Prime Minister pointed out, the Arab States feel that it is too revolutionary to move towards peace all at once, then we are prepared, as a first move, for an agreement leading to a cessation of hostilities and to non-belligerency. We made that proposal to the three Arab States—Egypt, Jordan and the Syrian Arab Republic—last March through the good offices of the United States of America, and so far have not been favoured with a reply. Only last week, an additional impetus to the prevalent feeling in the world that we must move towards negotiation was given by the decision of the Socialist International in Geneva. The second paragraph of a resolution passed by the Socialist International reads as follows:<\/p><\/div>\n "The Socialist International emphasizes the importance of ensuring that a peace settlement between Israel and its neighbouring States be based on negotiations and agreement between the parties in accordance with Security Council resolutions 242 (1967) and 338 (1973) and not be imposed on them from outside. It calls, therefore, for the reconvening of the Geneva Peace Conference on the basis of the two aforementioned resolutions and the original letter of invitation".<\/p><\/div>\n 9.\t<\/span>Considerable interest has been aroused by the so-called "peace offensive". Our problem is that we do not know which is the true voice of the Arab world. Do the soothing statements; made by President El-Sadat to visiting congressmen and the American media represent the true voice of the Arabs today, or do the statements which we hear in this Assembly hall represent the Arab voice? We have heard here in the past week statements by Arab representatives calling for the imposition of a solution, not for negotiations, and calling for war if we do not accept the solution imposed. Do those voices represent the true Arab voice?<\/p><\/div>\n 10.\t<\/span>Two draft resolutions drafted by the Arab delegations have been presented for the consideration of this Assembly. One is extreme, one-sided, biased and hostile to Israel. In that draft, Israel is condemned, sanctions against Israel are called for, the provisions of Security Council resolution 242(1967) with regard to withdrawal are falsified. More than that, the essence and spirit of Security Council resolutions 242(1967) and 338(1973) are violated, because the draft calls for effective measures within an appropriate time-table rather than negotiations between the parties, and the Palestinian Liberation Organization [PLO], <\/i>which is committed to the destruction of Israel, is to take part in the United Nations Peace Conference on the Middle East.<\/p><\/div>\n 11.\t<\/span>The second draft resolution has been couched in moderate terms and made purposely ambiguous so that it could allow of different interpretations. The second draft resolution is more subtle. Despite its apparent moderation it is designed to do away with the Geneva Peace Conference as originally constituted and to convene a new conference with different terms of reference and ground rules. Not by accident were the words "early resumption" of the United Nations Peace Conference, which appeared twice in working papers of this draft resolution, replaced by the words "early convening". Not by accident is all reference omitted to Security Council resolutions 242 (1967) and 338 (1973), which formed the agreed basis and framework for the Geneva Conference. Not by accident was reference to General Assembly resolution 3375 (XXX) introduced in the more extreme draft to indicate the basis and themes which the Arabs seek for the differently constituted peace conference. In brief, the aim is not to convene a conference for peace but to activate the Security Council against Israel.<\/p><\/div>\n 12.\t<\/span>The moderate draft resolution aroused the interest of many delegations. Then, however, the Ambassador of Egypt arose before the Assembly and spelled it out. He crossed the "t"s and dotted the "i"s. He removed all the ambiguity and called a spade a spade. He indicated, as did the Ambassador of the Syrian Arab Republic, that these two draft resolutions form one package, are linked one to the other and form one whole. He indicated further, with reference to participation in the Geneva Peace Conference, that he included the PLO. He also referred to the Secretary-General's initiative, because it, too, included the PLO.<\/p><\/div>\n 13.\t<\/span>By spelling it out, the Ambassadors of Egypt and the Syrian Arab Republic left no doubt in anybody's mind that here we were again, with the same old, time-honoured Arab call for a solution to be dictated to Israel in advance, and for pre-conditions to be laid down for a Geneva Peace Conference, both as to its composition and its recommendations.<\/p><\/div>\n 14.\t<\/span>For his part, President El-Sadat of Egypt spelled out what he meant by the Geneva Peace Conference. He pointed out in a number of interviews, such as in the Sunday Times <\/i>of London and in Time <\/i>magazine, that in his view successful negotiations at the Geneva Peace Conference would, of course, entail an Israeli withdrawal, but would not mean a renewal of diplomatic relations between Israel and its neighbours, would not mean the opening of borders, would not mean the establishment of commercial relations, would not mean the resumption of tourist traffic, and so forth. All this, he thought, should be left over to the next generation.<\/p><\/div>\n 15.\t<\/span>Have we not waited long enough? Have not enough generations suffered? Must we wait for the next generation? Why cannot we negotiate for peace?<\/p><\/div>\n 16.\t<\/span>We have made.it clear time and time again that we consider that the problem of the Palestinian Arabs must be solved within the framework of peaceful negotiations. Our Foreign Minister is on record to the effect that, given the proper basis for negotiations on the Palestinian issue, he would recommend to our Government informal consultations in advance between the three main elements—Israel, Jordan and the representatives of the Arab population in the West Bank—so that they could influence any solution which might be discussed. Prime Minister Rabin said only last week that it would be possible for people who live in the West Bank to be attached to the Jordanian delegation attending the Peace Conference or to come as part of the Jordanian delegation. The Prime Minister, addressing a joint session of the United States Congress only last January, emphasized the fact that he did not discount Palestinian representation in the peace delegation of Jordan.<\/p><\/div>\n 17.\t<\/span>At the Geneva Peace Conference in December 1973, seven of the 11 delegates in the Jordanian delegation were Palestinians.<\/p><\/div>\n 18.\t<\/span>All this is perfectly natural if you consider the fact that 80 per cent of the Palestinian Arabs live in Israel, Jordan, the West Bank and Gaza, that some 70 per cent of the Palestinian Arabs hold either Jordanian or Israeli passports, and that Jordan today is 80 per cent of what was the territory of Mandatory Palestine.<\/p><\/div>\n 19.\t<\/span>Our position in regard to the PLO was clearly defined by our Prime Minister only last week:<\/p><\/div>\n "The PLO" as he pointed out-"is not a partner for negotiations, for the simple reason that its political basis is non-acceptance of Israel and its right to exist."<\/p><\/div>\n 20.\t<\/span>The Palestine Covenant, as I have pointed out to you on many occasions, calls for the destruction of Israel, denies the existence of any link—historic or religious between the Jewish people and the Holy Land, and rejects any form of compromise as a basis for a solution.<\/p><\/div>\n 21.\t<\/span>Recently we have been regaled with stories of a softening in the PLO attitude. On 26 November, just over a week ago, the leadership of the PLO met in Beirut, and the following are some extracts from the resolutions which were passed by that leadership:<\/p><\/div>\n "The Palestinian Revolution warns against current Arab and international activity to bring to an end the Palestinian problem and to strike a blow at the hopes of the Palestinian people."<\/p><\/div>\n 22.\t<\/span>A further resolution decries the attempts by "Israel, the imperialists, and a number of Arab regimes to bring about a change in the PLO leadership".<\/p><\/div>\n 23.\t<\/span>Another resolution states:<\/p><\/div>\n "The leadership of the revolution will stand firmly against any international or Arab move to bring about a settlement in the area which will not include as a condition full national Palestinian independence for the Palestinian people in all its territory"-in other words, in the whole of Israel and Jordan.<\/p><\/div>\n And it continues: "The Revolutionary Command emphasizes that it rejects out of hand resolution 242 (1967) as a solution for the Palestinian people."<\/p><\/div>\n 24.\t<\/span>Here you have the answer to the insinuation which has been made that there is a change in the position of the PLO. Its position is quite unequivocal and absolutely straightforward: it is a position with which no self-respecting State represented here would contemplate any form of compromise, given the same conditions.<\/p><\/div>\n 25.\t<\/span>I emphasize again that we view the Geneva Peace Conference and the process of negotiations with one purpose, and one purpose only, in mind: that is, to achieve peace. We do not contemplate it as a step in the direction of national suicide for Israel -which is what the PLO's avowed purpose is.<\/p><\/div>\n 26.\t<\/span>We have been subjected to an enormous amount of talk, of prevarication, of double talk, to a verbal smokes-screen which hides the true purpose behind the words expressed. That is why we decided to present this draft resolution, which, if accepted as presented by us, would have the parties sitting down in Geneva tomorrow, negotiating for peace.<\/p><\/div>\n 27.\t<\/span>We are prepared to go to Geneva tomorrow, in accordance with the text of this draft resolution, without any "buts" or "ifs" or "perhapses"—without any pre-conditions whatsoever. The Conference is sovereign; let it decide about participants and substantive matters. <\/p><\/div>\n 28.\t<\/span>I have no illusions whatsoever about the strength of our position in this Assembly. I have no doubt but that every attempt will be made by the Arab delegations and their friends to torpedo this draft resolution, in one way or another, by means of amendments and other devices. If they do so, as they probably will, they will have performed a great service for us, because in this draft resolution we have stated clearly, simply and unequivocally what we are prepared to do. Any action taken to prejudice the prospects of this draft resolution in its present .form and language would only reveal the true intent of those taking such action. Those countries which will undoubtedly do as the Arab delegations bid them and participate in a move to vitiate this draft resolution will bear a heavy responsibility before history.<\/p><\/div>\n 29.\t<\/span>In bringing this draft resolution to this Assembly, may express the hope that we shall rise above the hateful diatribe and rhetoric that characterizes-deliberations on our problem; that we shall see—before us the prospect of a Middle East in which, as in days gone by, we shall both—Jew and Arab—join to recreate the great civilizations which we both represented in the past. I express the prayer that we may for a short minute set aside the hatred which characterizes this debate and, together, seek a way to move towards peace. The mechanism is there; it has been proved and found effective. I appeal to the members of the Assembly to support this draft resolution as presented to them, since it can bring about a situation whereby the parties mentioned in it will be sitting down facing one another—tomorrow, next week, next month, soon—negotiating for peace.<\/p><\/div>\n 30.\t<\/span>May I hope that they will join with us to set in motion the process which must lead towards peace. Israel is willing and prepared to enter into negotiations for peace today, tomorrow—whenever they wish. The members know as well as I do that they will be subjected to a renewed barrage of hatred and diatribe from the Arab representatives following this move of ours. I can only say this to them: you want to test us—to test our sincerity? By all means, do so: put us to the test; pass this draft resolution in its original form, without pre-conditions, and you will see for yourselves how we will react.<\/p><\/div>\n 31.\t<\/span>The PRESIDENT: I now call on the representative of Sri Lanka, who wishes to introduce the amendments contained in document A\/31\/L.25, and the two draft resolutions contained in documents A\/31\/L.26 and A\/31\/L.27.<\/p><\/div>\n 32.\t<\/span>Mr. KANAKARATNE (Sri Lanka): Mr. President, I appear before you and this Assembly this afternoon to introduce, on behalf of the delegations of India, Malta, Senegal, Yugoslavia and Sri Lanka, amendments, contained in document A\/31\/L.25, to draft resolution A\/31\/L.24, which has just been introduced by the representative of Israel.<\/p><\/div>\n 33.\t<\/span>This Assembly heard, last Thursday afternoon, at the commencement of the debate on the situation in the Middle East, what I may describe as an extremely eloquent statement by the representative of Israel singing an undisguised refrain for peace. And, as was to be expected, he repeated himself this afternoon in introducing the draft resolution presented by Israel, contained in document A\/31\/L.24.<\/p><\/div>\n 34.\t<\/span>But those of us who heard him last Thursday afternoon [87th meeting] <\/i>and those of us who have heard him this afternoon again must surely have noted that the gossamer robes of the angel of peace that he appeared in on both occasions will probably be seen, upon closer examination, to be instead a simple and crude "see-through".<\/p><\/div>\n 35.\t<\/span>What is this peace that the representative of Israel, quoting his Prime Minister's statement before the Socialist International in Geneva, was asking for? The times the word "peace" was used by the representative of Israel this afternoon and last Thursday, if counted, would surely number more than 100. But no one in this hall, indeed no Member of the United Nations committed to the obligations of the Charter, could ever refuse to hearken to a call for peace. But what are we talking about here when we are discussing the situation in the Middle East? It is not a question of peace by itself. Surely it is a question of peace with justice.<\/p><\/div>\n 36.\t<\/span>Has the representative of Israel overlooked that there can never be in the world among nations, within national boundaries or between communities within nations a peace founded on injustice—unless it be the peace of the graveyard or a peace imposed on the weak by the more powerful?<\/p><\/div>\n After 31 years of existence, the United Nations cannot now be steam-rollered into accepting a peace of either of those varieties.<\/p><\/div>\n 37.\t<\/span>The representative of Israel waxes eloquent rejecting, on behalf of his Government and country, a peace imposed by others. What precisely is the kind of peace he has been advocating here for the Middle Eastern countries in general and the Palestinian people in particular, if not a peace to be imposed by a group of States meeting at a so-called peace conference without the participation of the Palestinian people and their representatives? That, surely, must be the point to which this Assembly must address itself in evaluating the motivations of the draft resolution submitted by Israel in document A\/31\/L.24 and the motivations of the amendments to that draft resolution that I have the privilege and honour of introducing on behalf of five delegations.<\/p><\/div>\n 38.\t<\/span>We also are seeking to achieve peace, but we are seeking to achieve a lasting peace, a durable peace, which can be only a peace founded on justice and acceptance by all the parties immediately and most directly interested.<\/p><\/div>\n 39.\t<\/span>The Israeli draft resolution would have us call on Egypt, Israel, Jordan and the Syrian Arab Republic "to reconvene without delay at the Peace Conference on the Middle East under the co-chairmanship of the United States of America and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics in order to resume negotiations .. .". Is there not here a suggestion of a Hamlet without the Prince of Denmark? How can Israel, Egypt, Jordan and the Syrian Arab Republic reach, by negotiations, a permanent and just peace in the Middle East without the participation of the Palestinian people, without permitting the voices of the Palestinian people to be heard in those negotiations? We are told, in very authentic and acceptable terms, that it has commonly come to be recognized that there is a ."Palestinian dimension of the Middle East problem"; in using that phrase, I am quoting the report of the Secretary-General contained in document A\/31\/270-S\/12210 of 18 October 1976, in which the Secretary-General says, in paragraph 4:<\/p><\/div>\n 40.\t<\/span>If it is the common acceptance that there is a Palestinian dimension to the Middle East problem, and if the Israeli Government-as its representatives have often told us during the past few days—is in favour of a peace conference to negotiate a permanent peace, how then, in the name of reason, justice and the very peace of which the Israeli representatives are talking, can they justify omitting participation by the PLO representing the Palestinian people in such a conference?<\/p><\/div>\n 41.\t<\/span>It is to rectify that omission that the delegations of India, Malta, Senegal, Yugoslavia and Sri Lanka have proposed in document A\/31\/L.25 that we replace the operative paragraph in draft resolution A\/31\/L.24 by the following:<\/p><\/div>\n 42.\t<\/span>We are reminded that the basic Security Council resolutions that we should take into account are only resolutions 242 (1967) and 338 (1973). The representative of Israel a moment ago suggested that General Assembly resolution 3375 (XXX) is being introduced for subtle reasons. There is no subtlety about introducing in this hall a resolution of this very body adopted less than 12 months ago, in which the rightful place of the PLO was recognized. Did the world stand still between 1967 and 1975 because the Israeli Government wished it to stand still? Has not the position in the Middle East changed since 1967? It changed between 1967 and 1973; it changed between 1973 and 1975; and, as we all know, it has changed between 1975 and 1976. We refuse to be ruled by writs and resolutions which may have been very relevant at the time they were adopted but which have to be adapted and taken into account in conjunction with later developments justifying later resolutions of both the Security Council and this Assembly. It is for that reason that the sponsors of the amendments in document A\/31\/L.25 have included reference to General Assembly resolution 3375 (XXX) in the operative paragraph proposed in place of that appearing in document A\/31\/L.24.<\/p><\/div>\n 43.\t<\/span>One final difference that will be noted is that, in addition to the preambular paragraph in the Israeli draft resolution referring to Article 2 of the Charter, we have proposed the insertion of a second preambular paragraph, reading: "Recalling <\/i>all relevant United Nations resolutions concerning the Middle East".<\/p><\/div>\n 44.\t<\/span>It is, of course, somewhat ironic that in the Israeli draft resolution specific mention is made in the preamble to Article 2 of the Charter, recalling the obligations of all Member States to "settle their international disputes by peaceful means in such a manner that international peace and security and justice are not endangered". We may perhaps wish to pause and consider who in the Middle East has created the situation in which not only international peace and security and justice are endangered, but also the territorial integrity of nation-States in that area has been interfered with.<\/p><\/div>\n 45.\t<\/span>Article 2 of the Charter contains several paragraphs, as we know. The Israeli draft resolution refers to one of them—paragraph 4. But that Article states:<\/p><\/div>\n "All Members shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state …".<\/p><\/div>\n 46.\t<\/span>We certainly have no objection to joining with Israel and every other Member State in recalling to ourselves the obligations of the Charter. But those over-all obligations must be applied from time to time to specific situations of international tension as and when they arise; and those specific international tensions are governed by relevant resolutions of the United Nations General Assembly, the Security Council and other organs. It is for that reason that we have suggested the inclusion in the Israeli draft resolution of a reference to all relevant United Nations resolutions concerning the Middle East.<\/p><\/div>\n 47.\t<\/span>I have thus far spoken on the amendments to the Israeli draft resolution. The representative of Israel made a fervent appeal that, in the name of peace, the General Assembly support the Israeli draft resolution in its original form. We make an even more fervent appeal. If what the Assembly wants is not just an ad hoc <\/i>peace—meaning an absence of war, or a peace imposed, or a peace of the dead and the silent—then we appeal to this Assembly to provide the basis of a just peace, which will therefore be durable. That is why we have sought to redress the imbalance of the Israeli draft resolution; we have sought to make it a more balanced, fairer and more equitable approach to the problem facing the world in the Middle East. That is why we have suggested the replacing of the entire operative paragraph of the Israeli draft resolution by the one contained in document A\/31\/L.25.<\/p><\/div>\n 48.\t<\/span>On behalf of the sponsoring delegations, I commend these amendments to the serious and favourable consideration of the Assembly.<\/p><\/div>\n 49.\t<\/span>I come now to my duty as the representative of the current Chairman of the Group of Non-Aligned Countries to introduce draft resolutions A\/31\/L.26 and A\/31\/L.27, which have just been distributed. I take great pleasure, on behalf of the countries whose names appear in document A\/31\/L.26 and the countries whose names appear in document A\/31\/L.27, in formally placing these draft resolutions before the Assembly.<\/p><\/div>\n 50.\t<\/span>Draft resolution A\/31\/L.26 is a substantial one in the sense that it goes in some considerable detail into what we the sponsors and members of the non-aligned group of nations feel are the basic questions of the Middle East situation. What has given rise to the Middle East situation? As was stated in resolution 8, adopted unanimously by the Fifth Conference of Heads of State or Government of Non-Aligned Countries held in Colombo recently, <\/p><\/div>\n "… a just and lasting peace in the Middle East must be based on the following:<\/p><\/div>\n "(a) <\/i>the total and unconditional withdrawal of Israel from all the Arab territories occupied since June 1967;<\/p><\/div>\n "(b) <\/i>the Palestinian people's recovery of their national rights and the exercise of these rights, particularly that of establishing their independent State". [See A\/31\/197], annex IV, resolution [NAC\/CONF.5\/S\/Res.8]<\/i><\/p><\/div>\n 51.\t<\/span>These are the two basic concomitants without a solution to either of which there cannot be and there will not be a just and durable peace in the Middle East in our time.<\/p><\/div>\n 52.\t<\/span>That resolution of the Heads of State or Government of Non-Aligned Countries went on, in operative paragraph 5, to call upon<\/p><\/div>\n ".. . the non-aligned countries and peoples to adopt a firm stand against Israel's obstinacy and its endeavours to maintain the state of 'no war no peace' and [noted] that these attempts constitute a threat to the establishment of a just and lasting peace in the Middle East and a grave danger to world peace, security and stability ".[Ibid.]<\/i><\/p><\/div>\n In operative paragraph 12, the Colombo resolution condemned "… Israel for persisting in its policy of forcing a fait accompli <\/i>and for establishing colonies of settlements on Palestinian and all occupied Arab territories which is inconsistent with the principles of International Law, particularly that of the inadmissibility of the acquisition of territories by force and which constitutes an obstacle to a just settlement of the Middle East question". [Ibid.]<\/i><\/p><\/div>\n That resolution also condemned Israel's actions in the alteration of the geographical, demographic and economic features of the territories occupied and annexed by Israel and the destruction of their cultural aspects.<\/p><\/div>\n 53.\t<\/span>Now, all these provisions have been included in the various paragraphs of the present draft resolution, A\/31\/L.26, which we are introducing this afternoon, because, while proclaiming from the housetops and before the Socialist International in Geneva its desire for peace, on the ground, on the fields, on the soil of other peoples' territories, that same Government of Israel is proceeding to alter the demographic structures of those societies, to build permanent settlements, and to defend its actions publicly and unabashedly in the name of secure and defensible borders.<\/p><\/div>\n 54.\t<\/span>Are those the actions of an honest bonafide <\/i>advocate of peace in that area? How can all this be reconciled by the representative of Israel? Let him come up to this rostrum and explain to this Assembly with the same fervour that he has shown in flaunting the word "peace" how peace can be achieved when permanent settlements are being introduced into those areas which are not, under any conception of international law, territory belonging to the State of Israel.<\/p><\/div>\n How can this be done, unless it is a tongue-in-cheek offer of peace that is being made while back in the occupied territories great movement of forces and of population is being carried out under a calculated, consistent and persistent policy which, far from contributing to the success of a peace conference, regardless of who the participants are, will be a total and permanent obstacle to the realization of a just and fair negotiated settlement of the problems in the Middle East?<\/p><\/div>\n 55.\t<\/span>It is for those reasons that the sponsoring delegations of draft resolution A\/31\/L.26 have expressed their concern at that situation and affirmed in operative paragraph 1 <\/p><\/div>\n ".. .that the early resumption of the Peace Conference on the Middle East with the participation of all the parties concerned, including the Palestine Liberation Organization, in accordance with General Assembly resolution 3375 (XXX)… is essential for the realization of a just and lasting settlement in the region".<\/p><\/div>\n Without that participation, it is our firm conviction that there will be no productive, long-term, useful results from any gathering of other States under whatever co-chairmanship or by whatever name it is called.<\/p><\/div>\n 56.\t<\/span>The draft resolution goes on to condemn "Israel's continued occupation of Arab territories". Just because there is a temporary lull in the situation in the Middle East in the sense that there is no active fighting, we must warn the international community not to be misled by this situation. We believe that, if territories belonging to nations have been by aggression physically annexed and occupied by another nation-State, until that root-cause of the problem is removed there can be no just and lasting peace; there can be no artificially organized arrangement whereby for the time being people will lay down their arms. If there is a problem, and if we really, honestly and sincerely want a durable and fair solution of that problem, we must go to the roots of it. And who in this hall, including the delegation of Israel itself, can deny that the root-cause of the problem in the Middle East is the annexation by Israel of territories to which it has never been entitled and will never be entitled and the removal and deprivation by Israel of the right of the Palestinian people to a State of its own and to the enjoyment of human rights, which are ensured to all of us except that people.<\/p><\/div>\n 57.\t<\/span>The draft resolution also condemns the "measures taken by Israel in the occupied territories to change the demographic and geographic character and institutional structure of these territories".<\/p><\/div>\n 58.\t<\/span>We request once again "all States [who are so doing] to desist from supplying Israel with military and other forms of aid"; we request the "Security Council to take effective measures, within an appropriate time-table". The representative of Israel almost sniggered at the phrase "within an appropriate time-table". Are we going to continue to have the Middle East situation on our agenda for the next 31 years? Is another generation going to be victimized? Is another generation of representatives of our various Governments to come here and repeat the same arguments for another 31 years? A time-table is of the essence, because already we have waited far too long, watching without being able to take the necessary action the continued occupation of foreign lands by Israel and the Palestinians being deprived of their own rights to territory and to human standards of living.<\/p><\/div>\n 59.\t<\/span>Therefore, we request "the Secretary-General to inform the Co-Chairmen of the Peace Conference on the Middle East of the present resolution and to submit a report on the follow-up of its implementation to the General Assembly at its [next] session".<\/p><\/div>\n 60.\t<\/span>I have the pleasure of introducing also, on behalf of the sponsors, draft resolution A\/31\/L.27, on the Peace Conference on the Middle East.<\/p><\/div>\n 61.\t<\/span>In operative paragraph 1 the Assembly would request the Secretary-General:<\/p><\/div>\n "(a) <\/i>To resume contacts with all the parties to the conflict…, in accordance with his initiative of 1 April 1976, in preparation for the early convening of the Peace Conference on the Middle East;<\/p><\/div>\n "(b) <\/i>To submit a report to the Security Council on the results of his contacts and on the situation in the Middle East not later than 1 March 1977".<\/p><\/div>\n 62.\t<\/span>In operative paragraph 2 the Assembly would call for "the early convening of the Peace Conference on the Middle East, held under the auspices of the United Nations, not later than the end of March 1977".<\/p><\/div>\n 63.